Monday Morning Marketing Briefing

January 12, 2026 | Behind the CMO

Good morning, it's James here. Pinterest just lost its first-ever CMO after an eight-year run. When the average CMO tenure sits around four years, this departure marks the end of an era worth understanding. Meanwhile, the TikTok clock hits zero this week.

(Was this newsletter forwarded to you? Sign up here.)

The Lead: The End of Pinterest's Marketing Architect

Andréa Mallard is leaving Pinterest after an eight-year run as its first global CMO.

What happened: Mallard joined in 2018 and steadily expanded her remit beyond marketing into product design, communications, and youth safety. Under CEO Bill Ready, she helped reposition Pinterest's entire philosophy around "time well spent" rather than engagement-at-all-costs. Her final week starts now (Ad Age).

Why CMOs should care: Eight years in one seat is remarkable. The Spencer Stuart CMO tenure study shows average tenure at 4.3 years for Fortune 500 CMOs. Mallard nearly doubled that. But the more interesting question is what made that possible: a CEO who valued brand building, a platform differentiated enough to resist the engagement arms race, and a willingness to expand beyond the marketing silo into product and policy.

The take: Mallard didn't just run marketing. She helped shape what Pinterest actually was. That's the model for CMO longevity. Whether her replacement gets the same latitude is the real question.

Channel Shift

TikTok's deadline arrives this week. The US deal is set to close January 22 with Oracle and Silver Lake each taking 15% stakes (Bloomberg). But China's recent comments suggest less certainty than the timeline implies.

What to do: If you have significant TikTok spend, this is your last week to operate without a contingency plan. The most likely outcome is continuity under new ownership. But "most likely" isn't "certain," and the brands caught flat-footed in a worst-case scenario will have no one to blame but themselves. Have your YouTube Shorts and Instagram Reels backup ready to activate by Wednesday.

By The Numbers

25% of traditional search volume will shift to AI chatbots and virtual agents by end of 2026, according to Gartner (Campaign US).

This has moved beyond prediction into planning assumption. If a quarter of your organic traffic could evaporate into ChatGPT and Gemini answers, are you optimizing for how your brand shows up in AI responses? The emerging discipline is Generative Engine Optimization. It means structuring content so AI systems can accurately represent your brand in their answers. The early movers are already building for it. Everyone else is about to learn a hard lesson about rented traffic.

The Contrarian Take

The accepted wisdom: "CMO tenure is short because the job is impossibly hard. CMOs can't prove ROI, boards don't understand marketing, and the role is a revolving door."

Why it's incomplete: Mallard lasted eight years because Bill Ready gave her room to operate. She expanded into product, policy, and platform philosophy because Pinterest let her. The CMOs cycling through roles every 2-3 years aren't necessarily worse at their jobs. They're often working for CEOs who view marketing as a cost center to optimize, not a strategic function to invest in.

The real pattern: CMO tenure correlates more with CEO philosophy than CMO performance. We've designed an accountability system that punishes CMOs for problems they didn't create. The fix isn't better CMOs. It's better CEO-CMO alignment before the hire.

The Reading List

• "What Stays, What Changes, What Breaks: Trends Shaping Marketing in 2026" Campaign's framework for what actually matters this year versus what's noise.

• "The Definitive Digiday Guide to What's In and Out for Advertising in 2026" Provocative and contrarian. "Agentic web IN, IoT OUT" will make you think.

• "10 CMOs Set to Make Waves in 2026" Adweek's annual list includes OpenAI's Kate Rouch, Duolingo's Manu Orssaud, and Cadillac F1's inaugural CMO.

• "100 Ad Leaders Predict 2026 Marketing Trends" The comprehensive view from people actually making decisions this year.

Musical Chairs

NVIDIA hired Alison Wagonfeld from Google Cloud as its first-ever CMO (Adweek). When the most valuable company on Earth finally creates a CMO role, it signals something about marketing's strategic elevation. NVIDIA doesn't need demand gen. They can't make chips fast enough. This is a brand-building hire, pure and simple.

White Castle promoted Jamie Richardson to CMO after nearly 30 years with the company (NRN). Three decades to CMO at a single company. In a world obsessed with job-hopping and "career acceleration," White Castle just made the case for patience and institutional knowledge. Sometimes the best CMO is the one who's been there long enough to know where the bodies are buried.

One More Thing

The average CMO lasts less than four years. Mallard lasted eight. NVIDIA just created its first CMO role after becoming the world's most valuable company. Both stories point to the same thing: the CMO role is evolving, but not evenly. Some companies are expanding what marketing can be. Others are still treating it as a cost center. Before you take your next role, figure out which kind of company you're joining. The answer will determine your tenure more than your performance will.

See you next Monday. Make it count.

—James