It is November, and your 2027 budget is being negotiated in rooms you are not in. Finance is building the opex envelope. The CRO wants six more SDRs and has your program line in mind to pay for them. Product would like the onboarding emails moved into the app. RevOps has a slide titled "consolidating overlapping ops roles." An agency took your CEO to lunch last month. Each of them has a claim on the same money, and most will arrive with a sharper case than the one you planned to bring.
The aggregate numbers show who has been winning. Marketing budgets were 9.5% of company revenue in 2022 (Marketing Dive, May 2023) and 7.8% in 2026 (Gartner, May 2026). Measured against revenue, the envelope is nearly a fifth smaller. The mix inside it moved too. Paid media went from 25.6% of spend in 2023 to 30.6% in 2025, while labor and martech each lost about three points of share (Marketing Dive, May 2023) (Gartner, May 2025) (Chief Marketer, May 2025). Media is easy to defend in a spreadsheet, and headcount is easy to take.
Michael Porter built a tool for this problem, and it works pointed inward. Finance plays supplier, and Sales plays buyer. Product is the substitute, RevOps the rival, and agencies the new entrant. Score each force and spend your planning capital on the strongest one.
Porter, pointed inward
Porter's 2008 rewrite of his five forces article opens on a mistake. Managers "define competition too narrowly, as if it occurred only among today's direct competitors" (Porter, HBR, January 2008). The profit an industry creates gets divided by five forces: rivalry, the power of buyers, the power of suppliers, the threat of entrants, and the threat of substitutes. The sentence a CMO should carry into planning is this one. "The strongest competitive force or forces determine the profitability of an industry and become the most important to strategy formulation." His example is photographic film. Kodak and Fuji, its leading producers, saw returns fall to a superior substitute when digital photography arrived (Porter, HBR, January 2008).
CMOs make the narrow-definition mistake about their own budget. They prepare for one counterparty, the CFO, and lose seats to four others. I call the inward version the Inside Five. Marketing's version of profit is the budget and headcount it keeps after planning, and each force below has a lever on it.
Finance is your only supplier
Porter says a supplier group is powerful when it is "more concentrated than the industry it sells to" and when there is no substitute for what it provides. Finance is a monopoly supplier of capital, and you cannot shop for a second one.
The supply is tight. Gartner's 2026 survey of 401 marketing leaders found 56% lack the budget to deliver their 2026 strategy, and Gartner analyst Ewan McIntyre summed up the brief as growth, efficiency and transformation "without meaningful budget expansion" (Gartner, May 2026).
You cannot reduce Finance's concentration, so reduce its discretion. My default is to ask for a budget rule set once a year at planning, with program spend fixed as a ratio to the pipeline target. A rule turns every mid-year cut into a conversation about changing the target, which Finance rarely wants to have. Deviate when the company is protecting cash. Then accept a discretionary budget and get a written floor for headcount.
Score Finance a 3 if your budget was reset more than once in the last twelve months.
In Partnership with Mindstream
Beginner's Guide to AI Agents
Sales is your biggest buyer
Sales consumes marketing's output, which is pipeline. Porter's buyers gain power when the product is "standardized or undifferentiated" and when they can "credibly threaten to integrate backward and produce the industry's product themselves." For a CRO, backward integration is the outbound team. Every SDR added is a pipeline source that does not run through marketing, and the money to hire that SDR usually comes from your program line.
Differentiation is the defense. If your output is reported as a lead count, Sales can trade it for outbound activity one for one. Report marketing's output as closed-won revenue per program dollar, and ask for the same number on outbound headcount. My rule is that any request to move program dollars into SDR seats passes the same payback test on both sides of the ledger. When outbound beats marketing on that test for two straight quarters, concede the dollars and keep the targeting and content work that feeds the reps.
A CRO asking for marketing budget to fund sales headcount this cycle puts Sales at 3.
Product is the substitute
Porter defines a substitute as something that "performs the same or a similar function as an industry's product by a different means." Product now performs several of marketing's functions by different means. An in-app checklist does the nurture track's job, and a self-serve trial replaces the demo request. Buyers are pulling toward self-serve. In a Gartner survey of 632 B2B buyers, 61% preferred an overall rep-free buying experience (Gartner, June 2025).
Substitution only threatens work where marketing and product produce the same outcome. My position is to let product own the moments inside the product, activation and upgrade prompts included, and move marketing headcount toward buyers who have not signed up yet. If more than half of new revenue starts with a self-serve signup, rebuild the plan around filling the signup page. In an enterprise motion with no trial, this force barely registers.
Product scores a 3 when a product team runs lifecycle messaging your team used to own.
RevOps is the rival for the same seats
Rivalry inside the building is a peer function competing for the same pool. For marketing that pool is operations headcount and martech spend. The definitional fight over stages and attribution is its own problem, covered in The RevOps Land Grab, so this section is about seats.
In Gartner's 2025 survey, CMOs hoping to cut labor costs were also looking at "simplifying overlapping roles and centralizing critical capabilities" (Chief Marketer, May 2025). In my experience marketing ops overlaps with RevOps more than any other marketing role. When the CFO looks for duplicate seats, the marketing automation admin and the RevOps CRM admin sit on the same line of the spreadsheet.
My default is to hand RevOps CRM administration willingly and keep the people who build and run campaigns in the automation platform. Put campaign builders in another team's ticket queue and they work to that team's priorities. On a marketing team under ten people, consolidate fully and take a written service level with a named turnaround time.
Any consolidation proposal that names a marketing role puts RevOps at 3.
Agencies are the new entrant
The entrant is any outside bid for work your salaried team does. For now that bid is weak. In Gartner's 2025 survey, 39% of CMOs planned to cut agency budgets and 22% said generative AI had reduced their reliance on agencies for creativity and strategy (Gartner, May 2025). McIntyre expects those CMOs are "going to look to their third-party partners first before they look at their in-house team" (Chief Marketer, May 2025).
That cushion protects your team only while an agency line exists to cut first. The same survey had 39% of CMOs planning to reduce labor costs (Gartner, May 2025). The threat arrives when an agency or an AI vendor quotes your CFO a variable monthly fee for work your team does on salary. Switching costs are one of Porter's barriers to entry, and inside a company the switching cost is accumulated context. Keep in house the work that compounds with company knowledge, positioning and analytics among it. Buy execution that a new vendor could pick up in a month. Deviate when your team cannot staff the compounding work inside a quarter, and then write a handover of the working files into the contract. Know your fully loaded cost per deliverable before anyone quotes it to Finance.
If your CEO or CFO has taken an outside pitch for marketing work this year, agencies score a 3.
The Inside Five scorecard
Force | Who holds it | Porter's driver | Score 3 if | Default move |
Supplier power | Finance | Sole source of capital | Budget reset twice in twelve months | Annual budget rule tied to pipeline target |
Buyer power | Sales | Can build own pipeline | CRO wants your budget for SDRs | Same payback test on both ledgers |
Substitutes | Product | Same job, different means | Product runs your old lifecycle messaging | Cede in-product moments, chase non-users |
Rivalry | RevOps | Overlapping roles, shared pool | Consolidation plan names a marketing role | Give CRM admin, keep campaign builders |
New entrants | Agencies and AI vendors | Variable cost bid | Executive took an outside pitch | Keep compounding work, buy execution |
Score every other force a 1 or 2. Porter's rule sets the priority. The highest score gets your planning capital, meaning your prep time and the trades you will put in front of the CEO. A force at 1 needs one conversation a year, at planning, and the hours you save go to the force at 3.
My default is one force per planning cycle. When two forces both score 3, start with the one whose holder reports to the CEO. A CRO or CFO can move your budget in a single meeting, and an agency needs one of them to agree before it can move anything.
Before the first budget meeting
Fill in the five scores this week, before Finance sends the first draft of the 2027 envelope. Take the top row to your CEO as a one-page ask with the default move written out, and bring the payback math if the top row is Sales. If one of the rows is a decision two executives both think they own, the owner sheet in The Decisions You Both Think You Own settles who signs it.
The envelope has lost nearly a fifth of its weight against revenue since 2022, and labor and martech are the lines that gave. What marketing keeps of the 2027 envelope gets set in the next ninety days, in those five rooms.
James